I finally caught my first legit rides this past Friday. Once I broke the ice, I caught 4 of the next 5 waves (with one screwup in the middle when I flipped over the front of the board on my pop-up). Rode all the way into shore each time...at least 5-10 seconds every ride. So all-in-all I finally figured out all of the surfing intangibles (paddling, positioning, wave selection, takeoff, poppup) after about 10-12 hrs in the water. With my skateboarding backround, once I caught a wave and could do the popup successfully it was up it was really easy...even carved a little bit once. I think alot the success had to do with the surf conditions as well. It was really nice frequent 3 footers with occassional 4 footers...everyonein the lineup (fish and longboarders etc) were riding nearly every wave with ease. Last time out I was trying to battle 5-6 footers and getting really pounded and exhausted so this was a much more enjoyable. I made sure I ended the session with a nice ride to keep the stoke going.
As far as what board worked for me, its kinda weird. I had my 1st time success finally on the shortest board I've tried out. It was a 7'4'' board, not sure what to call it it was sort of a strange custom hybrid I suppose. It had a pointy nose like a shortboard, but was really thick and bouyant, easy to paddle and was also as wide as a minimal and very stable. The other 2 boards I've previously tried out was an 8'4'' minimal BIC rental and an 8' custom minimal. Personnally I really liked how this pointed nose board I had success on slices through the breaking waves when paddling out. The rounded nosed boards I've tried before get me beat around some when paddling out. Plus the smaller board gave me more success getting into position quicker to start my paddle and takeoff. The larger ones, seemed to require more time to get aligned properly and I missed wave alot more frequently. Maybe I'm just made to be a shortboarder who knows. I don't have very strong paddling skills though, that would be my downfall, but I feel more comfortable and in control of things on smaller boards. Larger boards feel like they are controlling me.