by dtc » Sun Jun 16, 2013 11:37 pm
Its really going to come down to your assessment of your current skill level, how often you will surf and how much frustration you can handle!
Obviously the longer/wider the board the relatively easier it will be. I wouldn't discount the minimal shape (wide nose, straight rails), say 7ft2-7ft6, potentially with a narrower tail (have a look at the Takayama scorpion - its probably the most extreme). This type of board will easily be suitable for at least 12 months - not a shortboard, but good paddling and still capable of a lot of manouvering etc.
Otherwise the larger hybrid. The two I mentioned before get a look of good reviews including from beginners/intermediates up to around your weight. They are big and thick and probably not easily duckdivable, but if you can duckdive easily the board is probably too small.
I do make the usual comment that its better to go too big than go too small at this stage - too small will just mean months of struggling and frustration, while too big just means you catch more waves...