I was using my knees for stability while paddling - basically just having pressure on both knees. It was preventing the board from pivoting under me. In other words, my knees were holding the tail down. The wave wasn’t lifting the tail, so I kept scooting forward and was pearling all the time.
I tried a longer board with similar width/thickness/shape thinking the tail would lift easier, and to my slight surprise it wasn’t really any better. So I tried getting the pressure off my knees and started catching waves. Then I went back to my regular board and was catching waves like never before!
I can’t believe how many waves I’ve robbed myself of over the past 2 years, but I’m so stoked to have figured this out. Hopefully this can help someone else.