mhk87 wrote: I guess what I meant is the waves seem to crest and then immediately break, but lets be serious I have no idea what I'm talking about
mhk87 wrote: I was more concerned there was a reason for the shorter boards, ie a longer board would be inappropriate for these beaches.
Speaking in general terms, because I don't know the spot you're talking about, but, yes, some breaks will suit shortboards (typically, steep or fast-breaking waves) while others will suit longboards (fatter waves, and long and peeling). That's not to say they can't be ridden by the "wrong" board necessarily, just that the wave suits the board.
So if your wave is breaking very fast and near the beach, it's likely to "a shortboard wave". Those waves aren't great for learning on because you need to deal with everything in a split second and you'll often be surfing into shallow water
Can you find any slower-breaking spots? If everyone out there is on a shortboard and surfing the shoredump, the chances are its not a learner-friendly wave.
Oh, and yes, everything DTC said... a softboard is fine for your first few goes in the water, but after that you'll need a proper board.
