You know, this sort of question always puzzles me.
Not the question asked by rrstein82, but by my own intrigue as to where people surf who need a bit of help from us here.
We could be giving some advice to some dude who we think needs a foamie because he is having difficulty catching waves at his local beach when in fact his difficulty is due to the lack of power of his tow in jet ski

!!!!!
So rrstein82, I hope we do help you at least a little in our answers ………

ANYWAY, my thoughts are ……..
I reckon you need a (few) lesson(s) – simple as that.
A few pointers about body position and wave selection would help you loads.
If you have the perseverance to stay in and get a wave an hour and still be keen, I think this is your only real option.
And its loads cheaper than a new board !
Give a lesson a go, you might be pleasantly surprised

.