by dtc » Sat May 14, 2016 4:05 am
When DBB says the board is too small, I think he saying it's too small to float you fully on the top of the water. Not that it's 'too small' for you to use. Like I said before, boards that are smaller (in comparison to weight) will sink a bit and will be harder to paddle as a result. But that doesn't mean you can't surf them - the issue of what board size is right for you is not determined by paddling. It's determined by wave catching, although obviously if you can only paddle for two waves a session due to fitness or injury etc, then that feeds into wave catching.
Ignore the tail, it follows what the nose is doing. Sure you could get a board with a different foam distribution (more in tail perhaps), but for the board you have do as Jaffa says and get a starting point and then adjust on feel as waikikichan says. Different water conditions, wind, swell size etc will all affect positioning on a day to day basis
What you end up with in terms of paddling ease or difficulty is what the board allows you to have. Maximise efficiency, but you can only maximise it to the boards limit