New east coast surfboard help

I'm looking for a new board. I live on the east coast, and this is pretty much the only place I surf. I go out a lot, even when the waves aren't good at all. Right now, I'm surfing a 6'4 NSP fish. It was the first board I bought, and I still love it. I'm getting to the point where I want something a little bit faster with more performance. I also can't duckdive my board ( I only way 120 lb.), so it's hard getting out on those bigger days. Right now I'm looking at the CI Biscuit, Fishcuit, or a custom board similar to the Biscuit. Are there any other boards I should look at? The average wave size I surf is 2-4 feet. Thanks.