Surfing Waves

Mys urf conditions are mostly mushy with 1-3 being average wave height. With he occasional good conditions of mushy 4-6 and during hurricane season we get some overheads. Looking for a shortboard that can suit my needs for all of these conditions. I really like pyzel and am thinking about either the pyzalien 2 or the astro pop was wondering if yall had any advice. Oh FYI im 5'9 140 and I live on the emerald coast in the florida pnahandle.

I have pyzalien 2 xl dims. It's like a shortboard. Hard to ride mostly goes in steep better waves. Can do any turn though which is fun in good surf.