Is it time for a new surfboard?

Over the past year I've moved to a new area with worse surf. As such, I've surfed less and lifted more. I've gone from about 155 lbs to 175lbs, at 5'10.
When I do surf, I now find I struggle to catch waves on my old 30 litre FC Fark. I'm thinking about a new board with more volume to catch waves earlier. Wondering how much I should go up in volume? Historically I haven't liked bigger boards, especially if they're hard to duck dive.
I'm hoping for a one board quiver. I like to surf small stuff but I often find myself in overhead waves. My current board fails me worst in large surf. I don't get into the waves quickly enough and end up with steep drops that I can't make.
I'm thinking of a board in the 34-36 litre range. I assume 4-6 more litres is a good step up in size that I'll notice? Also wondering about "one board quiver" recommendations. I like the idea of a Hypto Krypto, but kind of don't want the same expensive, commercial board that everyone is riding. Anyone know of any simular boards?
Advice and opinions appreciated
When I do surf, I now find I struggle to catch waves on my old 30 litre FC Fark. I'm thinking about a new board with more volume to catch waves earlier. Wondering how much I should go up in volume? Historically I haven't liked bigger boards, especially if they're hard to duck dive.
I'm hoping for a one board quiver. I like to surf small stuff but I often find myself in overhead waves. My current board fails me worst in large surf. I don't get into the waves quickly enough and end up with steep drops that I can't make.
I'm thinking of a board in the 34-36 litre range. I assume 4-6 more litres is a good step up in size that I'll notice? Also wondering about "one board quiver" recommendations. I like the idea of a Hypto Krypto, but kind of don't want the same expensive, commercial board that everyone is riding. Anyone know of any simular boards?
Advice and opinions appreciated
