Second surfboard for intermediate length and volume

[Itaiprz]

Heyy
I surfing for two years now
I surfed on 7 foam surfboard
I feel that I learned all the basics and i want move to the next level
My high is 6
My weight 190 lbs
I surf on beach break
Wave high 3 to 5 feet
I have a few options
1. Minimal 6.8 45L / I thinking that I outgrowth this board pretty quick
2. Minimal 6.8 40L
3. Shortboard 6 38L / i want this board for the maneuvers but i sure that he's big enough

I dont have option to take surfboard for test
what do you say

[Big H]

Number 1....you will have your hands full with that. That board is PLENTY maneuverable enough.

[waikikikichan]

None of the three. I would look for a 7’2” to 7’6” Hard board. Sponge boards are overly thick and wide and forgiving. They give you a false sense of confidence that you’ll be able to catch waves.

[Beginner77]

What are the advantages of a hard board over a foam/soft board?