Which board would suit me better?

i'm basically an improving beginner, looking to get my first board. Well I do have a really beat up 6'2 one I posted about in the surfing lessons section, which was fun but impossible to stand up on (for me and my more seasoned friend)!
So here are 2 options I have at the moment, both local from private sellers, and hand shaped.
Joe Hart big boy 7'2 x 20" x 3"
Or
Liquid Perfection 7'10 x 21 3/4" x 2 3/4"
I think they would both be a lot easier for me to surf but I am a 5'3 female of average (but not skinny!) build.
What do you think?
So here are 2 options I have at the moment, both local from private sellers, and hand shaped.
Joe Hart big boy 7'2 x 20" x 3"

Or
Liquid Perfection 7'10 x 21 3/4" x 2 3/4"

I think they would both be a lot easier for me to surf but I am a 5'3 female of average (but not skinny!) build.
What do you think?