Fin fibreglass vs plastic

Bought two exact same boards. One came with a blue fibre glass fin and the other came with a cheap plastic material. So I emailed the distributor saying that I want the blue fin because I think the shop didn't give me the original one that came with the board. Plus the blue one makes the board look better.
I would think the smooth surface would be more hydrodynamic than the rougher material?
They said:
Blue fin is 100% glossy fiberglass, black fin is matte composite so unfortunately logos don't adhere to this this material. Both center fins are same shape, composite actually is more durable and handles impact better.
The rough surface of the fin is intentional, it's more hydrodynamic than a smooth surface.
I would think the smooth surface would be more hydrodynamic than the rougher material?
They said:
Blue fin is 100% glossy fiberglass, black fin is matte composite so unfortunately logos don't adhere to this this material. Both center fins are same shape, composite actually is more durable and handles impact better.
The rough surface of the fin is intentional, it's more hydrodynamic than a smooth surface.