by dtc » Wed May 04, 2016 7:57 am
You could start off with standard cheap M5s as a thruster and see how that feels and then start playing around. I doubt a quad set from a 5'8 will be suitable, but you can always try on a nice small wave day and see what you think - no harm will be done. If you are planning on running it as a thruster/2+1, then obviously the quad set isnt suitable. Most mid lengths are not quads, not that I can say there is a particular reason for it, its just not usual (this may or may not be justified) - although I have seen quads on boards which are used on nice open faced point waves
Often for a mid length, the 2+1 set up doesnt require a very big '1', so it could be an M5/7 centre and 2x M3 or something like that. Or even smaller. I have a 7ft4 that sounds similar to yours and I'm 180lb. I have ended up with a centre fin that is between M5 and M7 (its a 'large M5' - the MF-1) and some side fins that are 4inch longboard side fins (smaller than M3s). But I went through a few different sets of fins and played mix and match with my other fins to get a combination I liked. For example, the full MF-1 set with side fins was terrible and didnt turn at all; I found 3 x M5s was ok but not quite loose enough for me. Pretty much I had to keep reducing fin size to get what I wanted and playing around with the centre fin placement in the fin box
Of course, you might end up with a similar feeling by running a larger centre (like a 6inch) and knubster (2 inch) side fins. I havent tried that
This is not a nose riding fin set up, in which case go with a dedicated single fin as you indicated - others will have a better idea of the shape and size for that and hopefully will chime in (waikikichan?)