0wnerer wrote:I was just wondering instead of buying a regular 6'2'' or 6'0'' shortboard, would it be a good idea to try a fish or one of those 6'0'' boards that are really wide and thick?
A fish and a shortboard are completely different types of boards and are surfed very differently. Neither are 'bad', it just depends on what waves you surf and what you want out of it.
A fish is good for smaller, fatter waves but arent any good for steep or fast waves.
So it depends also on where you surf etc etc. And if you want a fish, you'd probably go to well below 6'.
As everyone says, best to try out a couple of types of board if you can.
0wnerer wrote:Btw, for those of you have have 6'5'', 6'2'' and 6'0'' shortboards, when do you go back and use the bigger boards once you are used to the 6'0''? Or would you use the big boards at all?
Its mostly dependent on waves size and power. And also the characteristics of the board.
If you were to draw a graph of wave size Vs board size, it would be a U shape.
When the waves are small, you need the extra volume to get the speed... when the waves get bigger you can drop a few inches because the wave has enough power to push you along... but when the waves get really big, you need to be able to take off really early to avoid being splattered so you want some more length and volume.
I usually go... small waves 6'6 fishy shortboard, medium waves 6'3 quad, large waves 6'6 shortboard.
At your height/weight, it'll be less of an issue as even weak small waves will push you along nicely.