I'm new to this forum so forgive me if a similar question has already been asked.

I am looking for a short soft board to have some fun and not worry to much about the board. Throw it in the back of my car and go for a surf if I happen to see any waves

What would be more fun to surf in a wider variety of conditions? something more in the 5'6 - 6'0 range or 5'0 - 4'6 range.